Three degrees of separation - Waterloo edition

By Melanie Baker on February 28, 2008 - Comments (View)

The tech community of the Greater Toronto Area (GTA) draws its talent from a population of over 5 million people, nearly half of whom were born outside of Canada. Silicon Valley draws its talent from a population of over 2 million, many of whom are originally from other countries, or just other places in the US.

The tech community in Waterloo Region, on the other hand, draws its talent from a population of only around half a million. Many of those tech workers were born or went to school in the area.

Community connections and home-grown talent
This migration, or lack thereof, contributes to Waterloo Region’s unique technology culture. A large percentage of the tech community grew up together, went to school together, work (or have worked) together, play together, and have survived the ups and downs of trying to change the world together.

The result is a community where ‘six degrees of separation’ is closer to three.

School days and power plays
The region’s professional networks often germinate in college or university, expand into the business world after graduation, and flower as entrepreneurial partnerships. Likewise, many of the Region’s techies have worked together at more than one local firm, both in high tech and other industries.

In addition to working and going to school together, extensive networking results from local professional and recreational organizations as well, like Entrepreneur Week and the Hi-Tech Hockey League.

When everyone knows your name
An environment with fewer degrees of separation offers considerable benefits. Job hunting, recruiting, vendor recommendations, competitor validation, business development, and entrepreneurial opportunities are examples of how it’s easier doing business when ‘everyone knows everyone’.

One former eBusiness manager commented, “Recently I left the corporate world and jumped into consulting. My current position is a direct result of the networking connections I’ve made. I got a call out of the blue and within a week I was working on a 3-month contract.”

Some professionals employ a relationship-centric approach to network-building. One IT manager, also a U of W graduate, observed, “I don’t like to use it for business development, but I know of a lot of deals that started with a business relationship or friendship.”

She continued, “The best network extensions or connections happen organically and, for me, because I have a genuine interest in that person. I’m proud to say that I still keep in regular contact with a good number of people going back 10 years in the industry.”

Chemistry and lasting relationships also develop as a result of the tech sector’s volatility, producing “comrades-in-arms”. One local veteran noted, “There can be a sense of shared history, even if you didn’t actually work with that person before, because you know someone that they worked with, or know the story of their dot-com bust…”

The caveat of these benefits is, of course, that they only available to those within the community.

In a tight-knit community, reputation is sticky
A small world means tech professionals are always building their personal brands, whether consciously or not. One executive observed:

“The tech community [here] is small. If you’re authentic and good at what you do, your reputation/personal brand will build. Conversely, if you’re looking for the quick scam and are not professional, then word gets out and sooner or later, you won’t get much further in the industry. Building your brand (not in an overly promotional way) will create opportunities for you.”

Personal brands are built both inside and outside of the office. One proponent of tech events explained:

“You get to work with like-minded individuals… and by the end, not only have you had a good time and hopefully developed something, but you’ve had the opportunity of seeing how those people work. You get great insight into work habits and the knowledge level of those individuals. Intense tech events really force you to put your skills where your mouth is.”

It’s a small (work) world…
Of course, as anyone who grew up in a small town can tell you, it’s not always a good thing when everyone knows your business. Everyone interviewed commented that perceptions of people and companies stick around a long time.

One C-level executive with a background at several local tech firms elaborated, “Some hiring managers within the community do not have the capacity to see beyond a candidate’s previous experience, and may discern that [the person is] unable to deal with the necessary corporate ambiguity or take on new market challenges with vigor… and ultimately will not hire them.”

It isn’t only the locals who are exposed to the challenges of tight-knit culture. One Toronto-area IT manager looking to relocate to Kitchener-Waterloo commented, “I don’t know anybody in KW that I’ve worked with. As somebody who has been a hiring manager, I’ve certainly placed more weight on an internal recommendation based on a past working relationship. My guess is other hiring managers do the same.”

Who you know becomes ever more important the higher you go in corporate hierarchies. “I’ve noticed that in a lot of cases, management positions go to people who had a prior relationship with somebody senior in the organization. So as a non-local competing in a small job market, where I don’t have a lot personal connections, I’m probably going to be at a disadvantage.”

For companies, local candidates can be desirable for requiring less “ramp-up”, and being already somewhat familiar with the company’s business and culture. And there are no relocation costs if someone already lives here.

...and a small (personal) world
Impressions of people based on past experience or hearsay aren’t limited to the professional sphere. With work and social connections often overlapping, it can be difficult to keep work life and personal life separate.

One manager noted, “It’s hard to have your private life (or your “I love kitties” blog) stay private. You can be sure that if there’s a story about you, that it will be shared throughout the community.”

One woman recalled local online dating discomfort. “On a few occasions, guys would almost immediately ask if I was that girl from the gym or if I worked at Company X. One guy I hadn’t even met in person asked a co-worker, with whom I happened to be acquainted, about me. Creepy!”

Waterloo Region’s population isn’t going to hit 5 million in the near future. And our history of invention and entrepreneurship has a ways to go to catch up to Silicon Valley.

However, the Region’s unique, tight-knit culture, continued growth, and investment in future technologies and tech leaders make the tech community far greater than the sum of its parts.

Comments

Trevor Stafford Vote-kill Vote-no Vote-yes Trevor Stafford
feb 29 2008 16:29
10 Reputation Points

My question is this:

If Waterloo Region tends to recruit internally and via home-grown university talent, wouldn’t that limit growth?

I’m not talking about finding more developers, I’m suggesting that this model presents a finite number of experienced team leads and directors, which would stifle a company that was at, say, the 50-person or 75-person plateau.

Is this why a Waterloo-area company (Sandvine) is number 1 on the Deloitte Fast 50 but only one other company in the Region makes the list?

  Edit (for another )
Larry Borsato Vote-kill Vote-no Vote-yes Larry Borsato
mar 12 2008 09:29
1 Reputation Point

Excellent point, and clearly one the area seems to be grappling with.

Another problem I’ve noticed is the tendency to pigeonhole people into specific categories (i.e. developer, marketer,sale,etc.). Local companies don’t seem able to deal with people with multidisciplinary backgrounds.

I’m an engineer, software developer with over 20 years experience, former director of marketing, and I write for industry magazines. So I’m obviously not qualified to work locally because I don’t fit nicely into one specific box.

Many people I’ve worked with around the world are just like me, as opposed to one-dimensional. In fact, I assume most people are, and companies should be happy to take advantage of that.

  Edit (for another )
Saravana Rajan Vote-kill Vote-no Vote-yes Saravana Rajan
mar 12 2008 11:36
3 Reputation Points

I didn’t grow up here and came from India and have many friends in the tech community who have come from China, India, Eastern Europe etc.,

I agree the percentage of people, who came from outside Waterloo may be less compared to Silicon Valley or Toronto.

For example, in Silicon Valley, I can find almost 40-50% of my undergraduate classmates as most of the Indian IT folks end up in California due to the weather :)

Can’t agree more, its a small small world in Waterloo :)

  Edit (for another )
Melanie Baker Vote-kill Vote-no Vote-yes Melanie Baker
mar 13 2008 18:58
2 Reputation Points

Actually, Mr. Borsato, that very point is something I’ve been mulling over, and plan to write about soon. In good part because my background is the same—pretty much every job I’ve had, and every job I’ve been asked to do, has required hybrid skills and experience. (I’m sure this exists outside of tech, but I suspect it’s most noticeable there, especially with so many small companies with a dearth of bodies.)

I’m very curious to talk to folks who hire about hybrid roles, because I’m convinced it’s an ever-evolving business need, and is only going to get more so.

  Edit (for another )
Scott Valentine Vote-kill Vote-no Vote-yes Scott Valentine
mar 13 2008 19:52
10 Reputation Points

I think the piece is telling and well-written but the journalist in me wants attribution for the quotes. Too much “an insider said” stuff for my tastes.

  Edit (for another )
Melanie Baker Vote-kill Vote-no Vote-yes Melanie Baker
mar 15 2008 12:03
2 Reputation Points

I would have liked to have attributions as well, but in this case it was a matter of folks being willing to say things with that offer of “protection” that they’d never have commented on otherwise. Those folks are part of the community I wrote about, as am I—something we’re always aware of.

  Edit (for another )
Scott Valentine Vote-kill Vote-no Vote-yes Scott Valentine
mar 15 2008 14:06
10 Reputation Points

Yeah, that Waterloo tech mafia is notorious. Wouldn’t want you waking up to a severed Blackberry in your bed :)

Really, it comes down to the difference between blogging and journalism. They both serve a purpose.

SV

  Edit (for another )
Melanie Baker Vote-kill Vote-no Vote-yes Melanie Baker
mar 15 2008 17:25
2 Reputation Points

It ain’t the techies you gotta worry about so much ‘round here, it’s the Mennonites… Lucky for me, I’m both. ;)

And that’s exactly why the piece was posted as a blog post. We weren’t going for some big exposé, and there may well be folks who totally disagree with the opinions expressed.

That’s the good part – when the piece can be disagreed with, it can be fertile ground for more conversation.

  Edit (for another )
Scott Valentine Vote-kill Vote-no Vote-yes Scott Valentine
mar 18 2008 12:08
10 Reputation Points

Those interested in following up the blogging v journalism debate may be interested in checking out my own blog scottvalentine.blog.ca.

  Edit (for another )
Jim Murphy Vote-kill Vote-no Vote-yes Jim Murphy
apr 30 2008 12:55
8 Reputation Points

Well Melanie, as we shared recently, In Waterloo perhaps 3 degrees is more like 2, or 1!

I have to say that after moving back to Waterloo after 12 years in Boston I find the Waterloo (and Toronto) tech community a breath of fresh air. There is enough critical mass to make an ecosystem viable but intimate enough that you have broad and strong connections.

I’ve had a blast getting re-introduced over the past several months. Thanks to everyone that’s helped me out. I sincerely appreciate it. Makes me think I should have a more fullsome thank you on my blog at some point.

  Edit (for another )
blog comments powered by Disqus